🍣 The mistake we all make when evaluating work


Hi friend – Rob here.

Do you ever feel like we over-explain things?

That's today's topic.

Susan Sontag said this about art critics in her time:

"The old style of interpretation was insistent, but respectful; it erected another meaning on top of the literal one. The modern style of interpretation excavates, and as it excavates, destroys; it digs “behind” the text, to find a sub-text which is the true one."

I can't help but wonder that this is what we do in creative reviews.

Or with online discourse around brands and communications.

We look for meaning where there might not be one.

Sure, everything is communication.

But sometimes, the aim of the game is just to entertain.

For every hot take around the hidden meaning behind an ad, there are thousands of people who'd just go, "it's just lovely isn't it".

And you know what?

We should celebrate that.

The fact that people don't over-interpret.

That they just want a moment of levity.

Or to dream.

Over-layered communications is one of the biggest reasons ads don't cut through.

There's just too much.

It becomes cluttered.

Complicated.

Instead, how about if we:

  1. Have a clear view on the literal meaning behind the work? (simplify the message)
  2. And a single add-on around the metaphorical one? (exaggerate the execution)

I'll bet you we'd have much sharper, more interesting, respectful, entertaining, emotionally engaging work.

And much less excavated over-analysis.

Salmon Theory, by Rob Estreitinho

Helping savvy strategists swim upstream.

Read more from Salmon Theory, by Rob Estreitinho

Hey friend – Rob here. This is the last newsletter of the year, and goodness me what a year it's been. I was made redundant. I started a business. I lost my mother. I had my best year ever in terms of cash and confidence building. Ebbs and flows, eh? I hope you have a chance to take a break, genuinely turn off those notifications, and sleep in if you feel like it. I bring below 3x articles i wrote recently, and an event we're running in January. See you in 2025, and thanks for supporting...

Hey friend – Rob here. Here's what's been swimming around our brains lately: Synthesis-as-a-Service 5 things i’ve learned from Theophilus Wells IV The question i ask whenever i open a book [Bonus!] Social strategy, deconstructed Grab a cup of caramel tea, and let's get into it. Synthesis-as-a-Service And why it may be an underrated use case for hiring independent strategists. 5 things i’ve learned from Theophilus Wells IV Including directness, self-definition and why impostor syndrome is a...

Hey friend – Rob here. Do you worry about things? Or at all? My suspicion is that you worry far too much about everything. But don't worry, so do i. I think it's part of what makes strategists minimally good at the job. We are always wondering what else we might be missing. It's not a point of advantage, but it's definitely a point of parity. Worrying means we don't take anything for granted. And that's the first ingredient you need to challenge preconceptions about a problem. However. As you...